Our Civilisational Moment

Our Civilisational Moment

Manosphere violence? It’s Time to Talk about the Universities

Stephen McAlpine's avatar
Stephen McAlpine
Oct 30, 2026
∙ Paid

The manosphere is carrying a lot of blame these days. It’s responsible for porn addiction, poor treatment of women by men, and now, if the Prime Minister is to be believed, the violence that saw the terrible assault on MP Helen Haines that resulted in her losing both of her legs.

Now, while I can see the heavy hand of the online world being either responsible, or an accelerant for porn and misogyny, it smacks of sheer opportunism by Anthony Albanese to blame the assault on Haines on the same dreaded manosphere.

In fact the term itself has become a catch-all for any act of violence in the Western world these days. Bored young men being turned into angry or sexist young men by influencers on social media.

And suddenly, with that attack, the Prime Minister has been given a lifeline, or at least a distraction from his own domestic woes around suspect grants to golf clubs that he happens to frequent.

Not that he does not feel revulsion towards this dreadful act, but he has little, if any, philosophical or intellectual foundation upon which to pin it, if not the bogeyman of the hard-right digital world.

The already vague Digital Duty of Care bill is set to become an ever-more vague octopus, with tentacles that reach into freedom of speech, identity matters around gender, and now, the bogeyman of far-right politics.

Yet what is being conveniently forgotten, or at least overlooked, in the matter, an overlooking that only applies to the left of the political spectrum, is that the perpetrator in the Haines attack displayed an online presence that was a heady cocktail of deep green and pro-Palestinian far-left ideologies.

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Our Civilisational Moment to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
Stephen McAlpine's avatar
A guest post by
Stephen McAlpine
Exploring the current cultural moment in the West through the lens of orthodox Christian theology and ethical practices. Oh and a bunch of stuff about my haphazardous life.
Subscribe to Stephen
© 2026 John Anderson · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture